We're just like you.  We connected through an online dating service--OK Cupid, to be exact.  Our first date was at a fun Seattle tapas-and-sangria bar.  We fell in love.  We are engaged to be married.  We know that you, too, can find love.  Let us help you.

Father, We Confess: CatholicMatch Review (updated)

Father, We Confess: CatholicMatch Review (updated)


It was the tattoo-like banner ad around Valentine's Day that initially captured our interest. While this first confession may reveal our superficial natures, it also points to a smart and attractive ad campaign designed to appeal to a modern Catholic population.

There is something unexpected and incongruous about these modern icons being paired with a dating service for Catholic singles. Intrigued, we dug deeper, and discovered a well established dating site, filled with heart.

Second confession? While not exactly heathens, the Dating Gurus are not Catholic. Not even close. This doesn't prevent us from recognizing when the motivation to launch a business is largely a result of personal passion for and commitment to any given belief, product or service, good things can happen.

Faith Focused Dating

At a church picnic in the late nineties, roommates Jason LaFosse and Brian Barcaro found themselves in a discussion about the unique challenges facing Catholic singles in the modern dating world. This discussion led to the creation of Catholic Match's predecessor,, launched as a side business from a Pittsburgh apartment.

Fast forward five years after joining forces with new partner Mike Lloyd. The trio changed their name to, and began to witness exponential growth. Although newest partner Mike Lloyd died suddenly in 2014, the founding members honor his memory as they continue to uphold the same goals: 

  • Help single Catholics be in a better position to find their spouses
  • Maintain successful marriages,
  • Provide community built on a strong Catholic identity

 Oh Ye Of Little Faith

This is not your mainstream dating site in any sense of the word. Even those sites with more of a Christian foundation, such as like eHarmony or, are not as specific in their goals or target population. If you don't know this going in, you'll quickly discover it as you begin to register on the site. You'll either roll know it's right for you, or you will click off quickly.

Join CatholicMatch for Free!

Here's how it works:

After you register directly on the site (or through Facebook), you will answer multiple choice questions about background, family, habits, and appearance. Then, the faith-focused questions surface including:

Are you free to marry in the Catholic Church?

Yes / No / In Process / Unsure

How often do you attend Mass?

Almost every day / At least once a week / At least once a month / On special occasions / Never

There are also many very specific faith-based questions, including:

  • whether you have converted to Catholicism,
  • which diocese you belong to (based on your zip code)
  • your preferred liturgical style
  • belief in the literal meaning of the Eucharist
  • favorite patron saint
  • your feelings about papal infallibility
  • the right of women to become priests
  • your belief in the church's teachings about birth control, and abortion.

Each question about Catholicism includes parenthetical explanations on the specific teachings. For example:

Do you accept Church teaching on the Sanctity of Life?

Yes, I accept this teaching / No, I do not accept this teaching

What is the teaching? All life is sacred and each life, from the moment of conception to the moment of natural death, has a right to life, and therefore abortion, or any other method of barring a new life from implanting in its mother's womb or terminating a pregnancy is inherently wrong.

Next, complete a profile narrative, including:

  • your passions and things you look forward to
  • influences on your life, including your "faith-based" favorites (saints, prayers, and devotions)
  • foods, media, reading materials, sports and leisure activities, travel (including pilgrimages, destinations, trips).

Then, create the optional personal interview questionnaire, with up to 20 multiple choice questions (or use pre-formatted questions if you aren't feeling creative). These questions can help fine tune deal-breakers or must-haves, or simply help you gain insight into areas that are meaningful to you about the other people who are communicating with you.

Also optional is a lengthy temperament test, which we powered through, resulting in the discovery that one of us had a "Sanguine-Choleric" temperament?  Did you know that St Peter may have also been a Sanguine-Choleric? Didn't think so.

Helping To Reap What They Sow: The CatholicMatch Institute

The Catholic Match Institute For Dating & Marriage Readiness is an associated branch of the dating website, which provides advocacy, resources and scholarships to various Marriage and Family Life ministries who support of single Catholics. The Institute also hosts a non-preachy blog with interesting member stories and topic pieces. 

Membership Prices

  • New members are offered a 6 month subscription fee for $12.50 per month (with a guarantee that if you don't find a match in this time, that you will be able to extend for another 6 months for free.
  • 3 months for $19.99 per month
  • 1 month for $30.00 per month

As with all dating sites, it is free to sign up and create a profile, and look to your hearts content, but you are unable to communicate with anyone on the site, other than to receive and send an emoticon. It can be difficult for non subscribing members and guests to determine how many profiles are active vs. abandoned. Features for paid members include live chat, forum posting, and priority support.

What We Like

The attractive format, simple registration process, and upfront focus. There are no hidden agendas. This is clearly a site run by Catholics with the goal of promoting a Catholic courtship with the goal of Catholic marriage, values, and eventual family life.  We also like the Catholic Match Institute as a way of giving back to the community--practicing what they preach.

The site does not pander to the typical online dater in the 21-35 year old range, and has many mature daters in their database.

This is a thoughtful privately owned dating site with a lot of heart. There is no sleaze factor at all, and we like the 6 month guarantee. 

Possible Challenges

This Catholic dating site's singleness of purpose may limit the membership base in smaller, less metropolitan areas, thus making it necessary to widen your geographical search. The monthly fee is a bit pricey for a 1 month membership,. It is also challenging to tell who is only registered as a "free" (trial) member in the member data base, but this is not a unique challenge to this site. 

TheDatingGuru's Grade: A

Click on the banner above to check it out. No purchase necessary for the trial membership.

How I Met My Fiance on OkCupid: My Online Dating Love Story

How I Met My Fiance on OkCupid: My Online Dating Love Story

Online Dating for Geeks: Review of

Online Dating for Geeks: Review of